Estimated reading time 3 minutes
Table of Contents
Introduction
Do you want to know what the best organ sound is for performing baroque vs classical and romantic period organ music? Not all pipe organ music is the same, so the optimum sound you can use will differ from one style to another. Keep reading Advanced Tone Color Concepts for Playing Pipe Organ Music to learn how to get the best organ sound you can.
This article uses musical terms. For definitions, see the Glossary at the end of the post.
Advanced Tone Color Concepts for Playing Pipe Organ Music: What Is Spatial Line Strength vs Harmony Strength?
Spatial line strength helps linear melodies to hold together, but harmony strength allows chord tones to fuse.
- We saw something like this in the post Advanced Heterophony Concepts. North African heterophony works best when using instruments with very different tone colors.
- In addition, the tone color of the individual instruments doesn’t lend themselves to harmony, which isn’t a feature of Tunisian heterophony.
- Likewise, even though the tone of the rabab sounds strident to Western ears, its tone color is a critical element of making the style work.
Conversely, most Western instruments lend themselves to harmonic fusion.
- This means that there is an esthetic built into different types of instruments.
- This can vary from one society to another. However, it can also shift over time.
- In the next section, we’ll see how this has impacted organ music.
Advanced Tone Color Concepts for Playing Pipe Organ Music: Does the Design of the Organ Effect the Kind of Music You Can Play?
We also find spatial line strength and harmony strength in Western organ music.
Pipe organs have been designed so that the tone color facilitates the type of composition being played. Sundberg explains:
In Baroque organs the stops tend to have high spatial line strength. Therefore, they are apt to keep melodies together even when the music contains rather wide intervals. Further, such stops treat contrapuntal music in a friendly way, because they make the different simultaneously playing voices easy to track for the ear.
In romantic music from the late 19th century, it is often much more rewarding to pay attention to the harmonies than to look for the often-nonexistent counterpoint. Hence, the organ stops of the romantic organs were given great harmony strength, furthering fusion of simultaneous tones to chords.
Harmony strength and spatial line strength are opposites. Therefore, harmony strength produces melodic fission when wide intervals appear in a melody. And if one plays a simple four-voice chorale on an organ with great spatial line strength, the risk is that, for example, the alto voice jumps out of the harmonic structure, presenting itself as a solo voice, just to reveal, without shame or mercy, its lack of contrapuntal excitement. (Science of Musical Sounds 215)
Since spatial line strength and harmony strength are opposites, you can optimize an instrument for one kind of music or the other, but not both.
Advanced Tone Color Concepts for Playing Pipe Organ Music: What’s the Practical Application?
The practical takeaway is that you need to understand your music.
- Whether you’re composing or performing, you need to be aware if the music leans toward polyphony (like in the baroque period) or harmony (like in the classical and romantic periods).
- Therefore, when thinking about the tone color of your instrument (whether you’re using a synth or an actual pipe organ), you need to test sounds/stops to see which ones work best.
- Specifically, you need to listen to see if a sound lends itself better to one type of music over another.
- In other words, is it primarily harmonic or is it primarily contrapuntal?
- Thus, tone color is an important factor when writing and interpreting different styles of music.
The temperaments you use will also be an important factor in your sound and its impact on your instrument’s tone color.
Video: Bach D minor Toccata and Fugue (Meantone Temperament)
Final Thoughts
The takeaway points:
- Spatial line strength helps linear melodies to hold together, but harmony strength allows chord tones to fuse.
- Since spatial line strength and harmony strength are opposites, a pipe organ can optimize for one kind of music or the other, but not both (unless you use a synth).
- This means that there is an esthetic built into each instrument.
Have fun composing and performing!
Related Posts
- Simple Instructions for Pythagorean Tuning
- Intonation and Supplemented Equal Temperament
- How to Tune Your Incredibly Cool Microtonal Keyboard
- How to Write Quartertone Music that Sounds Amazing
- Tips for Synthesizing an African Balafon Style Xylophone Sound
© 2025 Geoffrey Keith
Glossary
What’s the Key Difference Between Countertenor, Baritone, etc?
Do you want to know what voice type you are? All the voice types discussed in this post are from the pool of male singers used in chorus, opera, musical theatre, and pop music. Some of these male vocalists can sing very high, while others can sing very low. However, it’s the quality of his voice that makes a male singer one voice type versus another. Keep reading “What’s the Key Difference Between Countertenor, Baritone, etc?” to learn what makes a singer a countertenor, tenor, baritone, or bass and how to tell them apart. Estimated reading time 2 minutes.
Read More
How to Mix Using a Digital Audio Workstation (DAW)
Do you want to know what DAW stands for? Do you need to learn how to mix songs using a digital audio workstation? DAWs are high quality sound recording software that will help you unlock your songwriting potential. Click to learn how to mix using a digital audio workstation. Estimated reading time 5 minutes.
Read More
Is the Suzuki Music Methodology Bad for Learning Piano?
“Is the Suzuki music methodology bad for learning piano?” Well, it really depends on what you want out of lessons. Like with many things, Suzuki music does some things well, and others poorly. Keep reading to learn the pros and cons of the Suzuki methodology when teaching children music. Estimated reading time 3 minutes.
Read More
Singing Shape Note Solfege Aeolian Melodies
Do you want to sing Eastern European folk melodies and mediaeval chants? Are you puzzled about how the aeolian mode works? Modes have been a feature of music from ancient times to today. Singing Shape Note Solfege Aeolian Melodies lets you explore the exotic sound of the aeolian mode. Estimated reading time 2 minutes.
Read More