Estimated reading time 4 minutes
Table of Contents
Introduction
Do you get frustrated when your hands-separate playing doesn’t seem to help with playing piano with both hands? Find out what determines how hard it’ll be to play with both hands and what you can do about it. Read more to answer the question, “Why doesn’t my hands-separate piano practice help with hands-together playing?”
This post uses musical terms. For definitions, see the Glossary at the end of the article.
When My Hands-Separate Piano Practice Does Help with Hands-Together Playing
“Why doesn’t my hands-separate piano practice help with hands-together playing?” How well your hands-together practice goes will depend on the difficulty level of the piece when compared with your skill level.
For some music, you might be able to easily shift from hands-separate work to hands-combined playing. It’s the music itself that determines how easy it’ll be to make that transition. For simpler music, try titling the book 90o to the right. For a detailed discussion of this strategy:
For other types of music, it’ll be easier to play hands-together than hands-separate. For more information:
When My Hands-Separate Piano Practice Doesn’t Help with Hands-Together Playing
“Why doesn’t my hands-separate piano practice help with hands-together playing?” Because sometimes you just need a little help. In other words, for complex pieces, you might find that you need to hear the piece played first. You can do this in a few ways:
- You can have a piano teacher demonstrate how to play the piece. The advantage to having a piano teacher is the one-on-one aspect of private music lessons. This allows for an individualized teaching approach with instant feedback. Also, a teacher can play the pieces at a variety of tempos, highlighting one hand or the other, while giving you tips for improving your playing.
- You can input the music into notation software, and have it play the music back for you. This won’t be as good as a human playing because it’ll have a somewhat robotic feel. However, if you can’t find someone to play it for you, and you can’t find a video version of it, this will work.
- You can search for your piece on YouTube. Once you’ve found it, click the settings icon, and set the playback speed to 0.5. This’ll help you hear how the music sounds, but at a slower tempo. When you’ve got it at 0.5 you can try 0.75 speed, and ultimately at full speed. However, instructional videos will be an inferior option to studying with a good piano teacher (even though learning piano on YouTube remains a trendy choice). A teacher can be flexible to meet your needs. A video can’t.
Video: New York State of Mind Arrangement
I had a student who struggled with learning an arrangement of New York State of Mind. Then, we found the arrangement on YouTube.
The video acts as a stand-in for me when my student practices the piece at home. Videos can supplement lessons, but they don’t really replace them.
Concluding Thoughts to “Why Doesn’t My Hands-Separate Piano Practice Help with Hands-Together Playing?”
“Why doesn’t my hands-separate piano practice help with hands-together playing?” While hands-separate playing may help for simple music, it may not always work for more complicated pieces.
To master hands-combined piano playing skills you need to have careful and conscientious practice. As a first step, hands-separate practice will usually be helpful. Working on each hand separately will simplify your learning tasks while reinforcing your muscle memory for each hand.
Be sure to start slowly, steadily increasing the tempo until you’ve got each part down. Then, you can try to put your hands together. However, when that isn’t enough, you may need to hear how the piece sounds when playing hands together. Have fun playing!
Related Posts
- Why Can I Play Piano Hands Together but not Separately?
- Ways Around the Difficulty of Playing the Piano Due to Short Fingers and Small Hands
- Do I Really Have to Learn Music Theory to Learn How to Play Piano?
- Why Do Pianists Occasionally Play Their Hands at Different Times as They Perform
- How Can Legato Notes Be Played Staccato?
- On the Electric Keyboard Can You Play Dynamics?
© 2023 Geoffrey Keith
Join me for in-person or online lessons today!
Back to the All-Purpose Music Tips and Topics category blogs page
Glossary
Piano Major Scales (Basic Fingering Concepts)
Do you want to understand piano scale fingering concepts better? At their core, all piano scales are based upon a central concept that helps simplify the fingering. Keep reading for piano major scales - basic fingering concepts. Estimated reading time 2 minutes.
Read More
Geoff will be an Exhibitor at LexSEPTA’s Special Needs Resource Fair
I‘ll have a table at the LexSEPTA Special Needs Resource Fair this Saturday. I will have my Perception Presentation with me, which shows what it’s like to have a learning disability, such as dyslexia or language-based learning disability. See you there! Estimated reading time 4 minutes.
Read More
Reading Music (A Quick Guide to How to Read Music)
Do you want to know how to read sheet music? It doesn’t matter whether you’re talking vocal sight reading, reading classical music, or understanding guitar tab, basic music reading will remain mostly the same. In some way, shape, or form all music notations track notes and rhythms, but how they do so will sometimes be different. Read more of "Reading Music (A Quick Guide to How to Read Music)" to get an overview of how to read sheet music. Estimated reading time 5 minutes.
Read More
What’s the Deal with These i-VII-VI-V and iv-V-VII Chords and Stuff? (Part 4)
Do your eyes cross when you try to figure out Roman Numeral analysis? Roman numerals are broadly used to analyze chords in songs. However, you’ll use some Roman numerals to specifically describe harmonies in minor keys. Read more to find out the answer to, “What's the deal with these i-VII-VI-V and iv-V-VII chords and stuff?” Estimated reading time 3 minutes.
Read More