Estimated reading time 3 minutes
Table of Contents
Introduction
Do you have a hard time singing in tune with the rest of the chorus when they sing loud? Have you ever wondered, “Can singers sing in tune even if they do not hear their voice?” Read more to find out how to fix this problem.
Today we’ll discuss about the eighth element from 10 Elements that Impact Singing in Tune. Specifically, this post talks about how volume affects vocal intonation. For practical examples to help you sing in tune (including sing-along soundtracks) see:
In addition, this article uses technical musical terms. For definitions, see the Glossary at the end of the post.
![How to Sing Key Changes in Tune - Choir - Sight Singing with Solfege - Can Singers Sing in Tune Even if They Do Not Hear Their Voice - Requiem Meaning: Music, Memorial, and Mourning [Video]](https://successmusicstudio.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/How-to-Sing-Key-Changes-in-Tune-Choir-1024x681.jpg)
Relative Volume Between Instruments Answers the Question, “Can Singers Sing in Tune Even if They Do Not Hear Their Voice?”
The relative volume between singers has an impact on harmonic tuning precision. Ternstrom and Sundberg found that a singer matched pitches best when the choir sang quieter than the vocalist. Which goes some way to answering the question, “Can singers sing in tune even if they do not hear their voice?”
- If the vocalists sang too loud, they could not hear the parts around them.
- Also, if they sang too quietly, they could not hear themselves.
“Problems are likely to arise if a singer’s feedback is so loud that it masks the [choir]…
“… or if, conversely, the [choir] masks the [vocalist], so that the singer cannot hear himself… This latter can, in fact arise even though one’s own voice is always at an advantage” (Intonation Precision of Choir Singers 59).
Intonation Precision and “Can Singers Sing in Tune Even if They Do Not Hear Their Voice?”
In Figure 5, Ternstrom and Sundberg have a graph showing the accuracy of the study’s singers over a wide range of decibels.
- How does this relate to the question, “Can singers sing in tune even if they do not hear their voice?”
- Well, the Figure 5 graph shows that singers had the greatest pitch precision when the choir sounded quieter than the vocalist by 5 to 25 decibels.
- When the choir sounded either too loud or too soft relative to the vocalist, the singer had greater difficulty with producing accurate pitch.
- Ternstrom and Sundberg add, “In Fig. 4, the curve /u:/ should intersect the 0-cent line near the [choir] SPL which was perceived to have the same loudness as the [vocalist]. The intersection occurred in the vicinity of the 20-dB [choir] level for most subjects” (63).
- In their study, Ternstrom and Sundberg tested the singers on two vowels. /a:/ had a lot of upper harmonics and /u:/ didn’t.
- The singers had a lot more trouble tuning the /u:/ than the /a:/ vowel. Nonetheless, both vowels hit the 0-cent line at about the point where the choir sounded 20 dB quieter that the vocalist. (The 0-cent line being the point at which no tuning error occurred.)
In addition, the above quote talks about the point at which the vocalists perceived they had the same volume as the choir. Namely, that singers must be relatively louder than those around them to keep from feeling overwhelmed by sound.
However, when they sing a little louder than the choir, they felt that the choir has a balanced sound.
Concluding Thoughts to “Can Singers Sing in Tune Even if They Do Not Hear Their Voice?”
“Can singers sing in tune even if they do not hear their voice?” The answer: no.
- This explains why many vocalists like to cup a hand between their ear and mouth to create a better volume balance for themselves.
- Thus, cupping the hand to the ear helps achieve better vocal tone, blend, and intonation.
- I have a similar example from when my wife and I taught children’s choir.
- It was years ago in a training session to prepare for leading the choir.
- Our instructor suggested using PVC pipe held between the child’s ear and mouth to help with pitch matching.
- Again, singers must be able to hear themselves and the others in the ensemble to get properly in tune.
Have fun singing!
© 2023 Geoffrey Keith
Join me for in-person or online lessons today!
Glossary
How Supplemented Equal Temperament Minor Keys Work
Frustrated with your out of tune synth chords? Do you want your brass, woodwind, and string programs to sound better? It’s not only the program you select which controls how your synth sounds, the tuning has an impact as well. I created Supplemented Equal Temperament (SET) to produce chords that sound better in tune than equal temperament (the piano’s tuning). Read more to learn how SET minor keys work. Estimated reading time 5 minutes.
Read More
Do I Really Have to Learn Music Theory to Learn How to Play Piano?
Do you want to give up on learning music theory? Does it seem pointless to you? Music theory can help with sight reading skills on the piano. It’ll be useful for improvisation and composition. It even helps with performance practice. If you still have an open mind, read “Do I Really Have to Learn Music Theory to Learn How to Play Piano?” to understand the ways it can help you to better play the instrument. Estimated reading time 4 minutes.
Read More
10 Elements that Impact Singing in Tune
Are you passionate about singing? Do you have a hard time singing or playing in tune? Learn the 10 Elements that Impact Singing in Tune. Estimated reading time 14 minutes.
Read More
Singing Rhythm Syllables in 2-4 Time
Do you have a hard time sight singing rhythm in time signatures other than 4-4? 2-4 gets used a lot in marches, so you often find it used in patriotic songs, making it worth learning. Read more to learn about singing rhythm syllables in 2-4 time. Estimated reading time 4 minutes.
Read More