Estimated reading time 3 minutes
Table of Contents
Making Sense of Why Treble and Bass Clef Are So Different #1: The Big Pattern
“How do I make any sense of the treble and bass clefs? Why are they so different?” To answer this question, you need to understand the grand staff, the pattern of the clefs, and middle C. Keep reading Making Sense of Why Treble and Bass Clef Are So Different to learn how the clefs work.
This article uses music terms. For definitions, see the Glossary at the end of the post.
Making Sense of Why Treble and Bass Clef Are So Different #2: Introducing Treble, Alto, and Bass Clef
Mobile users: for best results reading the music, tilt your screen 90o to the right.
The funny looking symbols to the left side of the music staves above are called clefs. Their purpose is to give you a refence note for the treble clef, alto clef, and bass clef:
- The treble clef points to the G above middle C.
- The alto clef points to middle C.
- The bass clef points to the F below middle C.
In addition, middle C on piano is used as a point of reference for the relative placement of the clefs.
Making Sense of Why Treble and Bass Clef Are So Different #3: The Trouble with Treble and Bass Staff Mnemonics
Most instrumentalists learn to read music using clef mnemonics:
- Clef mnemonics use memorable phrases to help musicians remember the line and space notes on the treble and bass clef staves.
- However, using the mnemonics for both treble and bass clef separately can obscure the pattern that unifies the clefs when they’re combined into the grand staff.
- That means that many musicians can become confused when they learn that the notes are different on the two music staves. This will be especially true if they haven’t been given the big picture via the grand staff.
Making Sense of Why Treble and Bass Clef Are So Different #4: The Grand Staff Pattern Saves the Day
Why do the treble and bass clefs have different positions for the notes on the staff? It helps if you understand the grand staff:
- When you join the treble clef staff and the bass clef staff (plus the note middle C), you’ll have the grand staff. (Which is used for keyboard music.)
- Think of the grand staff as a big eleven-line staff.
- It consists of the five-line treble staff on top, and the five-line bass staff on the bottom, with the short ledger line note, middle C, stuck in between them.
Look at the pattern of the notes on the grand staff:
- The bass clef staff starts with the bottom line-note: G. Then, it cycles through the musical alphabet going from line note to space note.
- After you finish the notes on the bass staff, you get the inter-staff notes of B, middle C, and D.
- Then, you end up on the bottom line-note for the treble clef staff: E.
The grand staff’s pattern makes the bottom line-notes different for the two music staves:
- Likewise, the bottom space notes are A on the bass staff and F on the treble staff, and so on for the rest of the notes.
- Thus, the eleven-line grand staff requires that the two music staves have different arrangements for the notes.
- So, this also explains why the music staves must have different clef mnemonics.
Making Sense of Why Treble and Bass Clef Are So Different #5: Let’s See What’s Up with Middle C
By joining the treble and bass clef staves into one big staff, it explains middle C’s name:
- Middle C isn’t the middle key of the piano, as many people assume. Instead, middle C is simply the middle note between the two music staves.
- In fact, middle C on piano got its name before the piano received its full complement of 88 keys.
- Middle C appears in the score only when needed.
Making Sense of Why Treble and Bass Clef Are So Different #6: Final Thoughts
Here’s a summary of Making Sense of Why Treble and Bass Clef Are So Different:
- The clefs give you a reference for the notes of the various staves. In addition, middle C is useful as a reference point for the relative positions of the music staves.
- Clef mnemonics, while helpful for learning the notes on the music staves, can obscure the relationship between the treble clef staff and the bass clef staff.
- The grand staff will help you see the relationship between the music staves.
Have fun reading music!
Related Posts
- Reading Music (A Quick Guide to How to Read Music)
- Why It’s So Hard for Someone with a Good Ear to Learn Sheet Music
- D’you Want Some Music Tips and Tricks I’ve Learned Over the Years?
© 2024 Geoffrey Keith
Join me for in-person or online lessons today!
Back to the All-Purpose Music Tips and Topics category blogs page
Glossary
2112’s Guitar Tuning
Do you want to know how Alex Lifeson tunes his guitar in the sci-fi rock opera 2112? How does experience with playing the violin or viola impact how guitarists tunes? This space opera may be the only example of a guitarist’s tuning being included as part of the finished product. At the beginning of the section entitled Discovery the hero finds a guitar, then tunes and plays it. Read more to learn about 2112’s guitar tuning. Estimated reading time 7 minutes.
Read More
Measuring a Song’s Success
Why does one person say a song is great and another says it stinks? In the “Art vs Commerce” post, we looked at two versions of the song “32 Flavors” and how the Boston Songwriters Workshop members reacted to it. Then, we looked at how and when the art vs commerce question arose. Finally, we asked, "How do you measure a song’s success?" Read more to learn the answer. Estimated reading time 3 minutes.
Read More
What is Required of Me to Write a Good Song if I Have No Experience with Songwriting?
Do you want to write songs, but don’t know where to start? To write a song, you need both imagination and the skill to put your imagination to work. If you see pictures in the clouds and have words and melodies pop into your head, songwriting will be well suited to your abilities. Click to answer the question, “What is required of me to write a good song if I have no experience with songwriting?” Estimated reading time 3 minutes.
Read More
How to Color Code Guitar Tab to Empower LD Achievement
Tablature creates a picture of the guitar neck. However, many LD students become confused by tab despite its visual appearance. In other words, they become dazzled by the shimmer created by the contrast of the black and white lines of the notation. Color-coding the strings helps reduce the confusion that students experience, assisting them in effectively reading the score. Estimated reading time 3 minutes.
Read More