Estimated reading time 3 minutes
Table of Contents
Introduction
Have you ever wondered, “Why do minor keys sound sad and major keys sound happy?” Has this phenomenon been hardwired into us, or does culture impact how we perceive scales? In fact, it’s a little bit of both. Read more to learn how this works.
This post uses some technical words. For descriptive links, see the Glossary below.
Melody Impacts Why Minor Keys Sound Sad
Why do minor keys sound sad? Because of the melodic relationships. If you play the white keys on the keyboard from C to C, it’ll have a bright or happy sound. Conversely, if you play from A to A, it’ll have a dark or sad sound.
This happens because the pattern of whole (w) and half (h) steps changes between the minor and major scales. The C major scale has a pattern of w, w, h, w, w, w, h. You can see this on the keyboard diagram below.
The white keys all have black keys in between them – except for E & F and B & C. E & F and B & C are the half steps from the previous pattern.
In contrast, the A minor scale has a pattern of w, h, w, w, h, w, w. Because our ears hear in relative rather than absolute terms, the pattern shift completely changes the sound. Listen to the soundtracks to hear the difference.
Minor Key:
Relative Major Key:
Mobile users: for best results reading the examples, tilt your screen 90o to the right.
Harmony Impacts Why Minor Keys Sound Sad
When you play notes together their harmonics interact. What are harmonics? Each note has a collection of pitches called harmonics that fuse together into one huge note called a complex tone. (See the chart below.)
When the critical bands between the harmonics in a chord overlap, it creates roughness. Suffice it to say that this creates the sense that some intervals and chords will be bright and others dark. You can hear this on the soundtracks below.
This partially explains why minor keys sound sad. For the rest of the explanation see the conclusion. For details on harmonics, fusion, critical bands, and the chart, read Harmony Is Tone Color.
I’ve provided the soundtracks to help illustrate the difference between minor and major sounds. However, the soundtracks have also been specially designed to help you sing in tune. If you’d like to see more Singing in Tune posts, click here for The Intonation Flight Simulator.
Minor Harmonies:
Relative Major Harmonies:
Concluding Thoughts on Why Minor Keys Sound Sad
We’ve talked about why minor and major keys sound dark and bright, but why do minor keys sound sad and major keys sound happy? Your culture attaches meaning to the keys.
Not all cultures hear minor and major keys as sad and happy. In India, they have major scales that they consider to be sad, while they think some of the minor scales sound happy.
Because you grew up in (or were influenced by) Western society, you’ve learned to interpret the bright sounding major scale as happy. Likewise, you’ve absorbed through movies, MP3s, and the internet that the dark sounding minor scale should be sad.
However, when listening to non-western music, it’ll be better to think of the scales in terms of bright and dark.
Therefore, the fact that minor keys sound dark to us has been hardwired into our bodies. However, the emotional interpretation of the dark sounding key as being sad comes from Western culture.
Related Content:
- How Does Your Brain Learn to Play the Piano with Two Hands?
- Ways Around the Difficulty of Playing the Piano Due to Short Fingers and Small Hands
- How to Overcome the Fear of Performing in Front of an Audience
- Why It’s So Hard for Someone with a Good Ear to Learn Sheet Music
- Do I Really Have to Learn Music Theory to Learn How to Play Piano?
- Why Do Pianists Occasionally Play Their Hands at Different Times as They Perform
- What Are the Small “>” Signs Above or Below the Notes?
- After They Can Sight-Read What’s Left for Musicians to Learn?
© 2023 Geoffrey Keith
Join me for in-person or online lessons today!
Back to the All-Purpose Music Tips and Topics category blogs page
Glossary
What Is the Precise Meaning of Scaffolding in Teaching?
“What is the precise meaning of scaffolding in teaching?” Scaffolding is an effective teaching method that’s designed to help students in the early phases of learning. It helps them close the distance between what they can do now and where they need to be in the future. Keep reading to learn more. Estimated reading time 2 minutes.
Read More
How to Explain an Octave to an Absolute Beginner Musician
Are you confused about what an octave is? Or are you a music teacher with a student that doesn’t understand how they work? Octaves are one of the most fundamental music theory concepts. When teaching music students, it helps to demonstrate them on a keyboard instrument, so I’ve created a keyboard diagram you can reference. Keep reading “How to Explain an Octave to an Absolute Beginner Musician?” to dive into the theory. Estimated reading time 2 minutes.
Read More
How to Sing R-Controlled Vowels in English
Do you need help singing words with sustained “R” sounds? Did you know that “R” is actually a vowel? However, it’s very closed, so you need special techniques when producing R-controlled vowels. Keep reading “How to Sing R-Controlled Vowels in English” to have a guide to how it works. Estimated reading time 3 minutes.
Read More
Brainstorming Your Song Titles
Are you stuck in a rut like the guy in the picture above? Do you want to know how to come up with vivid and memorable titles? Most of the songwriting experts agree that you should first write your hook, which often ends up being paired with your title. This means you need your title at the beginning of the songwriting process. Read more to learn how to go about brainstorming your song titles. Estimated reading time 4 minutes.
Read More