Success Music Studio

Should I Learn to Play the Piano One Hand at a Time or Simultaneously - Concert Pianist - Why Can I Play Piano Hands Together but not Separately - Can I Learn Singing on the Piano - Musical Talent and Giftedness - What Does the Exotic Sounding Word Bravo Mean at a Concert?

Should I Learn to Play the Piano One Hand at a Time or Simultaneously?

Facebook
Twitter

Estimated reading time 4 minutes

Table of Contents

Introduction

Have you ever asked yourself, “Should I learn to play the piano one hand at a time or simultaneously?” The answer to this question might surprise you. Read more to find out the practice strategies used by the most effective practicers.

This post deals with the question of whether you should learn to play the piano one hand at a time or simultaneously. Also, it discusses the general question of how to practice effectively. However, if you want specific tips on how to successfully play hands together, see:

This article uses music terms. For definitions, see the Glossary at the end of the post.

Do I Really Have to Learn Music Theory to Learn How to Play Piano - Do You Want Cool Chords for Your Song - Baby Grand - Should I Learn to Play the Piano One Hand at a Time or Simultaneously

Should I Learn to Play the Piano One Hand at a Time or Simultaneously: Effective Practice Strategies

Dr. Noa Kageyama, in 8 Things Top Practicers Do Differently, says that one of the most important practice strategies is to play with hands together.

Does this contradict what I said in the post How Does Your Brain Learn to Play the Piano with Two Hands? Should you learn to play the piano one hand at a time before playing hands simultaneously? As you read, you’ll see that the answer will be a nuanced one.

Kageyama quotes the piano performance research study by Robert Duke at The University of Texas. The study looked at the practice strategies for a group of music college pianists. The study’s list of top practice strategies:

  1. “Playing was hands-together early in practice.”
  2. “Practice was with inflection early on…”
  3. “Practice was thoughtful, as evidenced by silent pauses while looking at the music, singing/humming, making notes on the page, or expressing verbal ’ah-ha’s.”
  4. “Errors were preempted by stopping in anticipation of mistakes.”
  5. “Errors were addressed immediately when they appeared.”
  6. “The precise location and source of each error was identified accurately, rehearsed, and corrected.”
  7. “Tempo of individual performance trials was varied systematically… e.g. slowed things down to get tricky sections correct…”
  8. “Target passages were repeated until the error was corrected and the passage was stabilized…”

Should I Learn to Play the Piano One Hand at a Time or Simultaneously: The Most Effective Practice Strategies

So, “… hand-together early in practice…” doesn’t mean that you don’t do hands separate work. Rather, it means you don’t delay transitioning to hands together work. It’s not an either/or question.

For example, when working on a piece, you would start with a small section, say a bar of music.

    1. Work on the right hand, then the left hand, then both hands together.
    2. After this, work on the next bar using the same process.
    3. Then, you string the two bars together. Rinse and repeat.

Kageyama goes on to state: “The top performers utilized a variety of error-correction methods, such as playing with one hand alone, or playing just part of the excerpt, but there was one strategy that seemed to be the most impactful. Strategically slowing things down.

    • Should you learn to play the piano one hand at a time or simultaneously?
    • The top practicers didn’t all go straight to playing hands together.
    • However, they all slowed things down to correct errors.
    • Kageyama asserts, “Of the eight strategies above, there were three that were used by all three top pianists, but rarely utilized by the others. In fact, only two other pianists (ranked #4 and #6) used more than one…”

And the most effective practice strategies? Numbers 6 – 8. Even though playing hands together topped the list, identifying and correcting errors, slowing down tempos, and repeating until the passage “stabilized” got employed by five of the top six practicers.

Art vs Commerce in Songwriting - classical sheet music - How to Extract a Melody from Your Lyrics - Should I Learn to Play the Piano One Hand at a Time or Simultaneously - What is Required of Me to Write a Good Song if I Have No Experience with Songwriting - Why is Classical Music Interpreted Differently from Pop Music? Part 3 - Whats the Secret of Practicing Arpeggios

Concluding Thoughts to “Should I Learn to Play the Piano One Hand at a Time or Simultaneously?”

Kageyama states, “…the most striking difference between the top three pianists and the rest, was how they handled mistakes.”

The best practicers didn’t have an easier time learning or made less mistakes. Rather, they corrected their mistakes quickly so that they didn’t repeat them.

As you work on playing the piano one hand at a time then transitioning to playing hands simultaneously, you need to correct mistakes quickly.

You do this by slowing down, correcting errors, then repeating until you’ve got it. Within this context, you can bounce between playing hands separate and hands together.

Related Content:

© 2023 Geoffrey Keith

Newsletter Signup

Join me for in-person or online lessons today!

Back to the All-Purpose Music Tips and Topics category blogs page

Back to the Successful Music Student Blogs page

Glossary

Singing Shape Notes Solfege Lydian Melodies - Woman Singer

Singing Shape Notes Solfege Lydian Melodies

Do you want to be able to sing advanced modes? Are you confused about how the Lydian mode works? Modes are a feature of folk music around the world but are also both in jazz and 20th/21st century classical. Singing Shape Notes Solfege Lydian Melodies will help you master advanced modes. Keep reading to learn more. Estimated reading time 2 minutes.

Read More
How does your brain learn to play the piano with two hands - Changing Keys in Your Songwriting - Young Woman Playing the Piano

How Does Your Brain Learn to Play the Piano with Two Hands?

How does your brain learn to play the piano with two hands? Daniel Coyle, in "The Talent Code," tells us generally how the brain acquires skill, and I’ll give you specific tips for two-handed playing. Read more to find out how it works. Estimated reading time 4 minutes

Read More
It’s back to school time!

It’s Back to School Time!

It’s back to school time! I offer TWO FREE LESSONS so you can come in and check out my unique multisensory teaching methods. Estimated reading time 1 minute.

Read More
Why is Classical Music Interpreted Differently from Pop Music - Ludwig van Beethoven Bust - Beethoven (Why Did He Keep Composing After Deafness) - Singing Beethoven’s Beautiful Ode to Joy

Why is Classical Music Interpreted Differently from Pop Music? Part 3

“Why is classical music interpreted differently from pop music?” Interpretation has a very important role in performing classical music. This doesn’t mean that interpretation can’t be important in pop music. However, classical artists seem to be very aware of the process of how to interpret a piece of music. You can be too. Read more to learn how it works. Estimated reading time 2 minutes.

Read More